MYTHLOGIC Pollux 1400: Clevo's W150HR Tested
by Jarred Walton on August 23, 2011 12:00 AM ESTMYTHLOGIC Pollux 1400: A Different Kind of Clevo
Just about every Clevo notebook I’ve tested during the past several years has had a few standard features. They’re high performance, often quite loud under load, generally very expensive, and build quality never quite lives up to my expectations. The W150HR is a break from that tradition in a few ways, though the Pollux 1400 we tested does pack in some high performance and high cost extras (e.g. the SSD and i7 quad-core CPU). However, I tend to value such amenities, and $1600 for a relatively high-end laptop with very snappy overall performance is reasonable.
What’s not reasonable is the poor keyboard layout, plastic build quality, relatively high heat, and poor battery life compared to similar laptops. At $1000 for the base configuration, the Pollux 1400 still feels more like an $850 laptop. Actually, I have an Acer TimelineX AS3830TG that you can snag for $700 from Newegg, and when some aspects of the Acer impress me more than the Clevo W150HR, I get concerned. Ditch the 10-key layout on the keyboard and give me a frame that feels more like a Dell Latitude than an Acer Aspire and the price would be a lot more palatable. Improve cooling if you want a quad-core i7 processor in there (unless you like MacBook Pro levels of heat), and then focus some time on BIOS and power optimizations so that the 62Wh battery can hit at least six hours idle/five hours Internet and we’d be in business.
Along with the bad, we do have some good to help balance things. As far as beautiful displays go, the $120 upgrade pays dividends, and you won’t find such a display in any notebook costing under $1000 (and more likely, it will cost closer to $1500). Combine that with a fast i7-2720QM, 8GB RAM, GT 555M graphics, and one of the best current SSDs and you have a laptop that can do nearly anything you might want. It may not feel or look quite as nice as other $1500 notebooks, and four hours of useful battery life isn’t head-of-the-class material, but that will get you through most plane flights.
Overall, the Clevo W150HR/MYTHLOGIC Pollux 1400 works well, and in a vacuum I’d have no problem recommending it as a decent notebook with an awesome display. We’re not in a vacuum, of course, which means there are alternatives. At the premium end, there’s the Lenovo W520 and Alienware M14x, but Dell’s XPS 15 is right in the mix as well. Outside of these four options, I’m not aware of any other notebooks where you can get the same quality LCD without sacrificing battery life (e.g. you need Optimus), but if you don’t demand a good LCD there are numerous other alternatives. Ultimately, the balance of performance and features is good but not great, and I end up moderately interested but with concerns. It’s the finer details that are lacking but if you don’t want to move up to the Lenovo W520 (note that the Quadro 2000M is an upgrade to GT 555M while Quadro 1000M is a downgrade to GT 540M levels), this is the best way to get a laptop with an awesome 15.6” LCD.
Regarding MYTHLOGIC, our experience throughout the review has been positive. They were helpful and quick to respond to email messages, and their technical knowledge was good. It’s difficult to say whether they’re better or worse than their Clevo whitebook competitors, but they’re certainly in the mix. If you’re looking for a custom notebook or desktop, MYTHLOGIC has up-to-date offerings with the latest hardware and plenty of customization options, and their prices are reasonable. We would also like to thank them for working with Bigfoot to get us the review hardware, and for being patient with us throughout our lengthy review process.
22 Comments
View All Comments
CAndrews - Tuesday, August 23, 2011 - link
Is a review of the W520 coming?JarredWalton - Tuesday, August 23, 2011 - link
Sadly, no. Lenovo has not sent any review samples to us for a couple years.TotalLamer - Tuesday, August 23, 2011 - link
Oh really... ? What did you guys do to piss in their Cheerios? Haha.But on another note... any chance of a review on the 3830TG you mentioned? It's a nice looking machine and seems like the only notebook that can even come close to competing with everything you can get in a Sony Vaio SA (except for the 1600x900 display) but I've heard not-so-nice things about the heat dissipation
JarredWalton - Tuesday, August 23, 2011 - link
Yes, I'm working on the review. And it really *is* a nice looking machine with no major issues so far. I haven't tried stress-testing it for heat yet, and that may be the one area where it has some problems. We'll see.TotalLamer - Tuesday, August 23, 2011 - link
Yeah... I've heard there's throttling. Lots and lots of throttling. BAD throttling.JarredWalton - Tuesday, August 23, 2011 - link
I thought I saw something stating the GPU speed was 600MHz at one point when I was messing around (instead of the normal 672MHz of the GT 540M). Considering the dimensions of the chassis, I was actually quite shocked that they have the 540M in there.hybrid2d4x4 - Tuesday, August 23, 2011 - link
I briefly had the lowest-end config with the 2310 cpu and it throttled down to 1.3GHz under Prime95 without anything stressing the GPU, so I'm pretty sure I know what result you'll get, Jarred.Still, at $600 you get a really good feature set and hardware for the money but the quality control is non-existing. Of the 3 I had, 2 had corruption in HDMI output that made it unusable and 1 had half the keyboard keys not working. Going to play the lottery some more today to try and get a working one...
rallstarz - Tuesday, August 23, 2011 - link
Thanks for the review! I am trying to decide between the W150HR and the Dell XPS 15. Since I don't much mind for limited battery life and don't mind so much the nonstandard keyboard, it seems that the Clevo gives the best bang for the performance buck. My only concern is the longevity of the laptop. Do you know if pushing the thermal specs will significantly decrease longevity? Also (and I know you touched on this) for general use/gaming, does the system hit max cpu load for an extended period of time, or is your "worst-case" scenario truly a situation that the system does not generally hit?mythlogic - Tuesday, August 23, 2011 - link
Hey, I carry around one of these for my own use. It only gets REALLY hot (and never ever really hits 100 under "normal use") when i'm gaming on it, but just sitting on my lap its never too bad, or on a desk.JarredWalton - Tuesday, August 23, 2011 - link
Playing a game for a couple hours, you can expect to hit CPU temperatures of around 90-94C, which is hot but not quite 100C.